Guidance for reviewers
Reviewers help editors assess scientific quality and help authors improve their work through confidential, objective and constructive reports.
Before accepting
Accept only where you have relevant expertise and can complete a useful review in the agreed time. Declare competing interests, recent collaboration, institutional relationships or other circumstances that could affect impartiality. Contact the editor if the manuscript appears to identify an author despite anonymization. Do not delegate a review without permission.
Preparing a report
Assess relevance, originality, experimental or computational methods, uncertainty, data support, reproducibility, interpretation, limitations and references. Separate major scientific concerns from minor presentation issues. Explain recommendations with evidence and distinguish essential changes from optional suggestions. Do not request citations for personal benefit or use offensive language.
Confidentiality and integrity
Do not share the manuscript, use unpublished ideas or contact authors directly about the review. Report suspected overlap or ethical concerns privately to the editor with evidence. Do not upload manuscript content or review material to external generative AI services. The editor makes the publication decision.
Becoming a reviewer
Researchers may contact [email protected] with their affiliation, research areas, relevant publications and any persistent researcher identifier. Expressing interest does not guarantee an appointment. See the ethics policy and review process.
Policy text revised: 17 November 2026 · Contact the editorial office