Appeals & complaints
Authors, reviewers and readers may raise editorial-process concerns, appeal a decision or report a research-integrity issue without using abusive or threatening language.
Where to write
Write to [email protected], the complaints address already published by the journal. For editorial correspondence use [email protected]. Include the manuscript or article identifier, the decision or conduct being questioned, a concise explanation, relevant evidence and the remedy requested. Do not publish confidential reviewer identities.
Appealing an editorial decision
Submit a reasoned appeal within three months of the decision, identifying a material factual error, procedural problem or relevant conflict of interest. Disagreement with a judgement alone does not require reversal. The appeal should be assessed by an editor or board member not involved in the disputed decision, with independent advice where appropriate. The outcome and reasons should be communicated to the author. Acceptance is not guaranteed.
Process and ethics complaints
Complaints about delay, confidentiality, conflicts or reviewer conduct should be investigated proportionately and documented. A complaint about an editor should be referred to an uninvolved editorial-board member; the person complained about must not be the sole decision-maker. Research-integrity allegations may require evidence from authors, reviewers or institutions and follow the ethics policy.
While a matter is pending
Authors should clarify the manuscript’s status before submitting it elsewhere; simultaneous consideration is not permitted. If they wish to end consideration, they should request withdrawal in writing. Investigation time depends on complexity and third-party responses; no unverified response-time guarantee is stated here.
Policy text revised: 17 November 2026 · Contact the editorial office