Editorial process & peer review

The IJEAP editorial policy uses double-anonymized external peer review for research articles: reviewers are not given author identities, and authors are not given reviewer identities. Editors know the identities needed to manage the process. Complete anonymity cannot be guaranteed where a preprint or the subject matter identifies a study.

1. Initial assessment

The editorial office checks scope, required files, readability, authorship information, disclosures and compliance with research-ethics requirements. An editor assesses scientific suitability and possible overlap with earlier work. A manuscript may be returned for clarification or declined without external review with an explanation.

2. Independent external review

A suitable research manuscript is sent to at least two independent reviewers with relevant expertise; a third opinion may be sought where needed. Reviewers are selected for expertise and freedom from relevant conflicts, rather than nationality. Suggested reviewers are not automatically appointed and their identities must be checked. Reports should address methods, evidence, reproducibility, interpretation, relevant literature and clarity.

3. Decision and revision

The handling editor evaluates the reports and the manuscript and decides to accept, request minor or major revision, or reject. Reviewer recommendations inform the decision but do not constitute acceptance. Authors should supply a response to each comment and an identified revised version. Substantial changes may require another round of external review. A revision invitation does not guarantee acceptance.

4. Acceptance and production

Acceptance follows completion of scientific assessment and required integrity checks. Authors review proofs for accuracy. A formal acceptance notice is issued through the journal’s editorial workflow; an informal invitation or unsolicited email is not an acceptance decision.

Conflicts, confidentiality and timing

Editors must recuse themselves from manuscripts involving their own work or relevant personal, institutional, collaborative or financial conflicts. An independent editor handles submissions by editorial-board members. Review material is confidential and must not be uploaded to external AI tools. Review duration varies with reviewer availability, revisions and investigation needs; this page makes no guaranteed turnaround or acceptance promise. Authors may ask the editorial office about progress.

Appeals and reviewer guidance

See appeals and complaints and guidance for reviewers. Peer-review policies apply equally to special issues.

Policy text revised: 17 November 2026 · Contact the editorial office